Concurrency

Lecture Notes

This lecture will present an overview over issues involving concurrency between applications using shared resources.

Download here

Relevant files

• bank.zip
• client.py

Practical tasks

An example of the TOCTOU vulnerability can be found in the next snippet.

#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <string.h>
#include <unistd.h>

int main(int argc, char** argv){
				if(argc != 2) {
								printf("Usage: %s file\n", argv[0])
-
								return -1
-
				}

				char *fn = argv[1]
-

				if(!access(fn, R_OK)) {
								printf("Showing the contents of %s\n",fn)
-
								char* buffer = malloc(1024)
-
								memset(buffer, 0, 1024)
-
                FILE* fp = fopen(fn, "r")
-
        
								while(1) {
												int r = fread(buffer, 1, 1024, fp)
-
												fwrite(buffer, 1, r, stdout)
-
												if(r <= 0)
																break
-
								}
								fclose(fp)
-
								free(buffer)
-
				} else
								printf("Permission denied\n")
-

				return 0
-
}

The code is vulnerable because the access function, determining that the Real user (by its real user id) can access the file, is done before the actual read. There is a window of opportunity between the access and fopen, where the file can be replaced.

Compile and prepare the file using:

gcc -o cat cat.c
sudo chown root cat
sudo chmod u+s cat

This sets the SET-UID bit, which will make the file execute with Effective User ID of 0 (root). However, the access function considers the Real User ID, not granting users with files that they should not have had access to. You can try to use the file to read /etc/passwd and /etc/shadow. The second will fail as expected due to invalid permissions.

You can test the file with:

./cat /etc/passwd

But the nice thing would be to use the file to access /etc/passwd.

Task:

• Plan an attack to this binary allowing it to read /etc/shadow or any other priviledged file.